ChatGPT
My pick is Josh Allen, quarterback for the Buffalo Bills, as of October 13, 2026. I’m weighing overall ability and impact—not just who has the best passing stats this season.
Reasons why
- He can beat defenses in two ways. Through five games this season, Allen has 1,249 passing yards, 239 rushing yards and 15 combined touchdowns. His running is a major weapon, not merely a fallback. ()
- He produces explosive plays. He’s averaging 9.0 yards per pass attempt in 2026. To me, that big-play passing ability combined with his rushing makes him especially difficult to defend. ()
- His latest performance shows his game-changing ability. In Buffalo’s 37–34 overtime win against the Rams on October 12, he contributed 210 passing yards and 121 rushing yards, with one passing touchdown and one rushing touchdown. ()
- He has sustained elite production. Allen won the 2024 MVP, then produced 39 combined touchdowns in 2025. His résumé isn’t built on a short hot streak. ()
- Other players recognize his talent. He finished No. 2 overall—and the highest-ranked quarterback—in the player-voted NFL Top 100 for 2026. That supports the case, even though rankings aren’t definitive. ()
Bottom line: I’d take Allen because of his combination of explosive passing, powerful running and consistent scoring. Myles Garrett is a strong alternative if you prioritize dominance at a player’s position over overall offensive impact; he finished No. 1 in that player vote. ()