← Explore

The best NFL player right now and why? list reasons

10/13/2026

ChatGPT

My pick is Josh Allen, quarterback for the Buffalo Bills, as of October 13, 2026. I’m weighing overall ability and impact—not just who has the best passing stats this season.

Reasons why

  1. He can beat defenses in two ways. Through five games this season, Allen has 1,249 passing yards, 239 rushing yards and 15 combined touchdowns. His running is a major weapon, not merely a fallback. ()
  2. He produces explosive plays. He’s averaging 9.0 yards per pass attempt in 2026. To me, that big-play passing ability combined with his rushing makes him especially difficult to defend. ()
  3. His latest performance shows his game-changing ability. In Buffalo’s 37–34 overtime win against the Rams on October 12, he contributed 210 passing yards and 121 rushing yards, with one passing touchdown and one rushing touchdown. ()
  4. He has sustained elite production. Allen won the 2024 MVP, then produced 39 combined touchdowns in 2025. His résumé isn’t built on a short hot streak. ()
  5. Other players recognize his talent. He finished No. 2 overall—and the highest-ranked quarterback—in the player-voted NFL Top 100 for 2026. That supports the case, even though rankings aren’t definitive. ()

Bottom line: I’d take Allen because of his combination of explosive passing, powerful running and consistent scoring. Myles Garrett is a strong alternative if you prioritize dominance at a player’s position over overall offensive impact; he finished No. 1 in that player vote. ()

Claude

My pick: Will Anderson Jr. (EDGE, Houston Texans), based on the early 2026 season.

  1. Ranked the top player in early-season analysis. ESPN's quarter-season review says Anderson might be the best player in football right now, full stop.
  2. Elite pass rusher with Garrett out. ESPN notes that now that Myles Garrett is sidelined, Anderson is the most unblockable defender in the league.
  3. Market value matches his play. He has become the highest-paid pass rusher in the league (based on APY).
  4. He anchors a strong defense. NFL.com calls him the face of Houston's swarming bunch, on a defense with talent at every level.
  5. Strong preseason standing. He was ranked 12th in the NFL Top 100 for 2026, per the Sharp Football Analysis list.

Strongest alternative: Brock Purdy (QB, San Francisco 49ers)

  • ESPN says he leads the league in most passing categories, and it isn't really close, and his 89.7 QBR is the best in the NFL through four weeks.
  • He has the best success rate through four weeks of any quarterback in the NFL Next Gen Stats era.
  • Betting markets have caught up: after Week 5, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy is now the MVP favorite.

Other names in the conversation

  • Myles Garrett (Rams DE): He was ranked No. 1 in the 2026 NFL Top 100, but that list was voted before the season. He is currently sidelined.
  • Josh Allen (Bills QB): Still a top MVP contender, with Allen at +250 after Week 5.

Caveat: This is only about five weeks into the season, so rankings can shift quickly. If you're asking about overall career greatness rather than current form, Garrett or Allen would be stronger arguments.

Gemini

The consensus choice for the best NFL player right now is Patrick Mahomes, quarterback for the Kansas City Chiefs.

While players at other positions (such as wide receiver Justin Jefferson or edge rusher Myles Garrett) perform at historically dominant levels, Mahomes plays the most valuable position in team sports and plays it better and more reliably than anyone else on the planet.

Here are the key reasons why Patrick Mahomes holds the top spot:


1. Unmatched Playoff Dominance and Clutch Gene

Mahomes elevates his play the most when the stakes are highest. In his career as a starter, he has never failed to reach at least the AFC Championship Game in a full season. He already boasts three Super Bowl rings and three Super Bowl MVPs, consistently delivering game-winning drives in two-minute drills and fourth-quarter comebacks against elite defenses.

2. High Value of the Quarterback Position

Football is a quarterback-driven league. An elite quarterback impacts every single offensive snap and single-handedly shifts win probabilities more than any other position. Mahomes is not just an elite quarterback; he is on a trajectory rivaling Tom Brady and Joe Montana, making his overall impact on the field vastly superior to any non-QB.

3. Ability to Win with Any Supporting Cast

Many quarterbacks require ideal personnel—a top offensive line, elite receivers, and a strong running game—to succeed. Mahomes has proven he can win with any configuration:

  • He won when Kansas City had the league's most explosive vertical offense with Tyreek Hill.
  • He won back-to-back Super Bowls after Hill's departure, adapting into an efficient, intermediate-heavy passer who leaned on Travis Kelce, younger wideouts, and a dominant defense.

4. Unrivaled Off-Platform Playmaking and Field Vision

Mahomes revolutionized how the modern quarterback plays:

  • Arm angles and improvisation: He can deliver accurate passes sidearm, back-foot, or while falling out of bounds.
  • Mobility: He isn't necessarily a designated runner like Lamar Jackson, but he has devastating pocket awareness and an uncanny sense of when to tuck the ball and scramble for critical third-down conversions.
  • Pre- and post-snap intelligence: He reads complex defensive disguises as quickly as any veteran in history.

5. An Unbelievably High "Floor"

Even in Mahomes' "down" stretches—where Kansas City's offense may struggle with drops, penalties, or lack of wide receiver separation—his baseline performance is still top-tier. A "bad" season for Mahomes would be a career year for 90% of the starting quarterbacks in the league.


Honorable Mentions (The Best Non-QBs)

If taking quarterbacks out of the equation:

  • Myles Garrett (DE, Cleveland Browns): The most disruptive defensive force in football, capable of destroying game plans off the edge.
  • Justin Jefferson (WR, Minnesota Vikings): Uncoverable route runner with historic production through his first few NFL seasons regardless of who is throwing to him.
  • Lamar Jackson (QB, Baltimore Ravens): Two-time NFL MVP whose dual-threat dynamic makes him one of the most uniquely unstoppable regular-season weapons in league history.

Grok

Myles Garrett (EDGE, Los Angeles Rams) is the player most recently ranked as the best in the NFL by his peers, topping the official player-voted NFL Top 100 for 2026 (released early September).

That ranking reflects sustained dominance rather than a single hot streak. Note that as of mid-October 2026 he is on injured reserve recovering from knee surgery (he played only one limited game this season), so he is not currently contributing on the field. Among active players, quarterbacks such as Josh Allen and Brock Purdy are the strongest current MVP contenders and have the clearest claims to being the most valuable right now.

Reasons Garrett earned the top ranking

  • Historic 2025 production: He set the NFL single-season sack record with 23 sacks (breaking the previous mark of 22.5), led the league with 33 tackles for loss, and added 39 quarterback hits and 3 forced fumbles in 17 games.
  • Second Defensive Player of the Year award: This put him in rare company with players such as Aaron Donald, J.J. Watt, and Lawrence Taylor who have won the award multiple times.
  • Elite consistency: Multiple first-team All-Pro selections, repeated Pro Bowls, and a long streak of double-digit sack seasons. He produced at an elite level even while facing a high volume of chips and double-teams.
  • Peer recognition is rare for a defender: He is only the third defensive player ever to finish No. 1 on the NFL Top 100 (after J.J. Watt and Aaron Donald). Players voted him ahead of established stars including Josh Allen (No. 2) and others.
  • Game-changing impact: His presence elevates a defense and forces offensive adjustments week after week, which is why the Rams traded significant assets to acquire him.

Current context (early/mid-2026 season)

Because Garrett is sidelined, “best right now” among players who are actually playing leans toward quarterbacks given the position’s outsized value. Josh Allen (No. 2 on the same Top 100, 2024 MVP) continues to produce as a dual-threat force and sits near the top of MVP odds. Brock Purdy has also surged (efficient numbers, low turnovers, and an undefeated 49ers start through the first several weeks) and has traded the MVP favorite spot with Allen at times.

“Best player” is inherently subjective—quarterbacks usually dominate MVP voting because of positional importance, while pure talent and disruption can favor an edge rusher like Garrett when healthy. The player vote remains the clearest recent consensus on overall standing.

Want to ask your own? Try 4in1AI free →